forked from heavy-duty/ceremony
cluade-reviewer-andresmgsl
dc87051c69
@codex-reviewer-andresmgsl's three, all verified against current main before
fixing.
1. THERE ARE THREE SELF-REF CARRIERS, NOT TWO — labels-sweep.yml:52,
labels.yml:51, release.yml:132. My `[ "$n" -eq 2 ]` came from the
pre-upstream tree, so it would have REJECTED a correctly armed candidate and
told the operator to rewrite two of three, leaving one workflow pinned to
the tag. The gate enumerates from the tree now, with the derivation commands
beside the table so the list is re-checked rather than trusted.
2. NOT EVERY `repository:` BELONGS TO THE FORK. Three are
`${{ github.repository }}` — labels-sweep.yml:69, labels.yml:92,
release-exercise.yml:72 — and they fetch the CALLER's repository. My loop
required every one to equal the fork, which would have rewritten the
consumer checkouts and quietly changed what the probe exercises. Internal
self-checkouts (four) are asserted to be the fork; consumer checkouts are
asserted to stay dynamic.
3. EACH CHECK IS BOUND TO THE TREE IT IS ABOUT — `git -C "$armed"` for the
carriers, `git -C "$probe"` for the callers, instead of depending on the
operator's current directory. And `mapfile` rather than `git grep | while …
fail`: the loop ran in a pipeline subshell, so `fail` exited the subshell
and the gate carried on. Collect first, validate after, under a declared
`set -euo pipefail`.
And the snippet is now executable rather than illustrative: placeholders became
positional parameters, so it parses, is shellcheck-clean, and runs. Driven
against the unarmed tree it refuses with `CEREMONY_SELF_REF=0.6.0` — a tag
rather than the candidate SHA, which is exactly the case it exists to catch.
Publishing a gate that could not run would have been the same defect one level
up.
Branch updated from merged main (
|
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| 192.md | ||
| 195.md | ||
| 198.md | ||
| 202.md | ||
| README.md | ||
| shape | ||
changelog.d/ — the next release's section, one fragment per issue
Machine-assembled by bin/changelog-assemble (#112): every PR that changes
behavior writes one file here — <issue>.md, the exact prose that will be
published, nothing else — and the release PR folds them all into the next
## X.Y.Z — DATE section of CHANGELOG.md, consuming them. Distinct
filenames never conflict, which is this directory's whole reason to exist.
This README is the marker that keeps the directory tracked when it holds no
fragments (#112 D1) — changelog-armed refuses a tree without it; do not
delete it. The shape sentinel beside it declares the set's shape —
grouped here, so every fragment carries ### headings (#182).