A users file naming zero users is a valid instruction to revoke every
operator on the box, and it is indistinguishable from the file a stray '>'
produces. The per-user warnings apply already emitted arrive after the
decision and scale wrong: twenty operators is twenty lines of scrollback,
so the signal was loudest exactly where it read as noise.
The /etc/rig/users ledger draws the line apply needs. An empty file against
an empty ledger is an unambiguous no-op; against a populated one it closes
every named door. Only the second now stops, states how many operators are
at risk, and requires explicit consent: --yes, RIG_YES=1 (the
installer-family variable bin/rig's uninstall_confirm already reads), or a
y on a TTY. Without a terminal and without consent it exits 2 in that same
refusal's words, rather than assume a yes it cannot ask for or hang on a
prompt nothing can answer.
A confirmation, not bootstrap's flat refusal of the same file (#57/#59):
bootstrap asserts who lives on a box, apply converges, and converging to
zero stays a legitimate de-provisioning. Ledger entries already marked
revoked do not count toward the number, so a second identical run stays the
silent no-op convergence promises.
Mass revocation below the empty-file bright line is deliberately still
ungated — that needs a threshold someone has to justify.
Refs #65
The trait was named for who lives on a box; what it decides is whether
root SSH stays open as the control plane's automation door. Those are
different questions, and `dev-server` proved it: an unattended VM-host
appliance nobody lives on, correctly class=human because its root door
must close. After #76 gave `-server` the job of naming the machine
family, that box carried a suffix saying server and a trait saying
human. `dev-server --root-door closed` says what is true, once.
Unlike #76's role rename this field is read back on live machines, so
the compat read is mandatory rather than courteous: one resolver,
root_door_of, reads both vocabularies and every consumer goes through
it — close-root's gate, apply's note, and bootstrap-tenant's
machine-marker guard, which used the presence of `class=` as its "is
this a real fleet machine?" test and would otherwise have let a tenant
converge clobber a live box. New markers are written as `root-door=`
only. Markers carrying both fields in disagreement, or neither, fail
closed with a re-run-bootstrap repair.
Fixture markers are kept deliberately at the retired spelling (the
convention #76's pre-rename-cp fixture established) and pinned at both
consumers; deleting the compat arm turns ten checks red.
Closes#77
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Role `box` resolved to exactly one action, `usermod -aG incus`. That is
the socket — step 1 of the five `box grant` performs. Without the other
four (the user-<uid> project, its narrowing to boxnet and only boxnet,
the snapshot and backup allowances clone and `box export` ride, and the
shipped box-net profile installed into that project) the user's first
`box new` refuses for want of a box-net profile, so apply's promise —
the users file is the fleet's source of truth — was not kept for this
role. Worse, until an admin arrived by hand the user held an `incus`
membership with no converged project, and incus-user would lazily hand
them a stock unhardened NAT bridge: a state box's own contract forbids.
On host=yes apply now calls `box grant <user>` per box-role user. rig
calls box's grant rather than reimplementing four fifths of it — the
"rig never installs Incus" boundary is about installation, not
invocation, and grant is already script-callable: idempotent,
root-or-sudo, stdin-pinned, with its own run-as-the-user touch.
Three decisions the code carries in comment form:
- Ordering. The call sits after `useradd` (grant opens with a getent
passwd and refuses an unknown account) and after the other groups, so
a user whose grant fails still lands with everything rig owns outright.
- Failure granularity, split the way the host= guard beside it already
splits. A missing box CLI on host=yes dies, like the missing incus
group: a broken VM host, not a per-user accident. A per-user grant
failure warns and continues — one box-role user somewhere in the fleet
must not stop apply everywhere VMs don't live. host=no and marker-less
boxes keep their existing skip-with-warning untouched.
- The group ADD is deferred to grant, while `incus` stays in the wanted
set so the exact-convergence loop never strips a box-role user's
socket. Grant's rollback only reaches a membership that run added, so
rig opening the socket first would leave a failed grant unable to
close it. And grant is the authority on whether the group belongs at
all: for an incus-admin member it deliberately does not add `incus`.
An incus-admin member is warned, never fatal: box grant refuses them
today, which heavy-duty/box#99 fixes box-side with no rig change needed.
Closes#49
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`users apply` converged group `incus` with a bare `gpasswd -d`, the same
move it makes for `rig-admin` and `rig`. Those two are rig's. `incus` is
box's, and `box revoke` does strictly more with it: it says out loud that
supplementary groups are read AT LOGIN, so a session the dropped operator
already holds keeps the Incus socket until that session dies, and it hands
over `loginctl terminate-user <user>` as the remedy.
rig logged "removed <user> from incus" and moved on. An operator who
dropped someone from the users file and watched apply succeed believed the
VM access was gone — and was wrong for as long as that user held a session.
Both removal paths — the per-user convergence loop and the dropped-user
sweep — now route the incus group through one `drop_incus` helper that
calls `box revoke`, keeping a single owner for the group. Never `--purge`:
that deletes the user's boxes, images and project, and destroying someone's
running machines is not a convergence step; it stays an explicit admin act.
The exit code is not trusted (the #12 lesson bootstrap already applies to
box's installer): a revoke that returns 0 with the membership still
standing has not closed the socket, so the effective state is checked and
rig falls back to removing the group itself — as it also does on a host
where box is not installed. Every fallback path carries the session warning
in rig's own voice, because the silence was the bug. The absent-group case
needs no new guard: `id -nG` cannot report a group that does not exist, so
the existing `in_group` test at both call sites is already false on a
host=no box or one where `box setup-host` never ran.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
users apply consulted the host= trait only when group incus was ABSENT,
so a host=no or marker-less box that nonetheless carried the group handed
box-role users a bare `usermod -aG incus` — the socket with no tier, which
incus-user answers by lazily building an unhardened project under whoever
opens it.
The marker now decides in both directions through one pure gate,
assert_marker_hosts_vms, so the verdict is identical whether or not the
group exists. The marker wins over the machine deliberately — it is the
box's declared identity and every other host= decision already treats it
as authoritative — but not silently: when the group exists and the trait
disagrees, the skip names the contradiction and rig bootstrap as the fix.
Closes#58
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The headline of #17: rig can verify a lot locally, but never that the
operator HOLDS the admin's private key. Seeding authorized_keys from root's
current /root/.ssh/authorized_keys turns that unprovable claim into a proven
one — the operator is connected as root right now using one of those keys.
The users file gains the literal key-field token '@root', shape-validated in
the parse pass (exit 2, pre-root-check, testable non-root); apply resolves
it once after the root check, dies with the repair when root has no keys to
seed, copies key lines verbatim (options included — rig will not silently
widen what a key can do), and writes seeded keys first with literal lines
appended, so the cmp-guard keeps re-runs convergent to root's then-current
keys plus the literals.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Seven review findings on the users family, each with the harness check that
would have caught it:
- Invoker gate (apply + close-root): %rig's sudoers rule is binary-scoped but
not argument-scoped, so `sudo rig users apply --file <me-as-admin>` made
role rig silently root-equivalent through the very command that granted it.
Identity management now refuses any sudo invoker outside rig-admin; direct
root (bring-up, a root shell) proceeds.
- Offboarding revokes SSH, not just the password: a '!'-locked password is
not a closed door under UsePAM — Debian sshd still honors the pubkey. A
dropped user's account is now expired (usermod -L -e 1, the switch PAM
actually enforces) and authorized_keys is renamed to
authorized_keys.revoked-by-rig — access revoked, data kept, convergence
never destroys. Present users get their expiry cleared idempotently, so a
re-added user comes back to life.
- The ledger remembers: two-field lines ('name active' / 'name revoked',
legacy bare names read as active), so dropped users no longer vanish from
rig's memory on the next rewrite. status now reports the ledger state
corroborated by the account's real expiry — passwd -S read L for everyone
(apply locks all passwords always), so its locked/active was meaningless —
and flags a mismatch loudly as drift.
- Perms are part of the converged state: ~/.ssh and authorized_keys ownership
and mode converge on every run, not only when content changes — StrictModes
treats them as load-bearing, so drifted perms were a broken login that
"already converged" lied about. Only the content write stays cmp-guarded.
- close-root's admin-door gate checks the StrictModes shape per candidate —
ownership, group/world-writability of home/.ssh/authorized_keys, a real
login shell, an unexpired account — and names which check failed. It proves
the door SHOULD open, not that it does; the separate-session advisory stays
load-bearing.
- Usernames are validated in the parser's one-pass refusal matrix
(^[a-z_][a-z0-9_-]{0,31}$): 'fo|o' corrupted the parser's own '|'-delimited
stream, and a leading '-' read as a useradd flag mid-convergence.
- The box role is trait-aware: on a host=no box an absent incus group skips
the role with a warning and converges everything else — one box-role user
in a fleet-wide file must not abort apply everywhere VMs don't live.
host=yes still dies pointing at box setup-host; a classless marker warns
toward a bootstrap re-run.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operators become a declared fact, not an accumulation of adduser runs: a
line-based, bash-parseable users file (no YAML, no jq — a rig box has
neither) names each user, their roles, and their keys, and apply converges
the box to exactly that. Roles map to groups (admin→rig-admin with full
NOPASSWD sudo, rig→rig sudo for the rig binary only, box→incus with no
sudo — box's setup-host owns Incus, rig only asserts the group). Every
password stays locked always; the SSH key at the door is the
authentication. A user dropped from the file is found via the /etc/rig/users
ledger and locked, never deleted — deleting frees the uid and rots
attribution. The sudoers drop-in lands only after visudo -c passes, because
a bad file under sudoers.d takes down all of sudo. Class never gates apply
(#26: a shared root login is unattributable, so operators belong on every
class); the marker only colors what root SSH does next. The whole file is
validated in one pass before the root check, every error named with its
line, so refusals are provable in the non-root harness through the sourced
parser.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
