#17's table said runner 'can close root once an admin user is proven'; the
class model (#26) superseded the per-role call, and close-root refuses on
class=server — runner's class. The gate does not change: the refusal message
now explains itself (server-class machines are automation identities whose
management plane IS root SSH; a CI box meant to be administered like a human
machine is --class human at bootstrap, not an exception), and the README's
identity-model section records the divergence in one paragraph. README also
documents the @root seed token and close-root's reachability proofs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The headline of #17: rig can verify a lot locally, but never that the
operator HOLDS the admin's private key. Seeding authorized_keys from root's
current /root/.ssh/authorized_keys turns that unprovable claim into a proven
one — the operator is connected as root right now using one of those keys.
The users file gains the literal key-field token '@root', shape-validated in
the parse pass (exit 2, pre-root-check, testable non-root); apply resolves
it once after the root check, dies with the repair when root has no keys to
seed, copies key lines verbatim (options included — rig will not silently
widen what a key can do), and writes seeded keys first with literal lines
appended, so the cmp-guard keeps re-runs convergent to root's then-current
keys plus the literals.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Seven review findings on the users family, each with the harness check that
would have caught it:
- Invoker gate (apply + close-root): %rig's sudoers rule is binary-scoped but
not argument-scoped, so `sudo rig users apply --file <me-as-admin>` made
role rig silently root-equivalent through the very command that granted it.
Identity management now refuses any sudo invoker outside rig-admin; direct
root (bring-up, a root shell) proceeds.
- Offboarding revokes SSH, not just the password: a '!'-locked password is
not a closed door under UsePAM — Debian sshd still honors the pubkey. A
dropped user's account is now expired (usermod -L -e 1, the switch PAM
actually enforces) and authorized_keys is renamed to
authorized_keys.revoked-by-rig — access revoked, data kept, convergence
never destroys. Present users get their expiry cleared idempotently, so a
re-added user comes back to life.
- The ledger remembers: two-field lines ('name active' / 'name revoked',
legacy bare names read as active), so dropped users no longer vanish from
rig's memory on the next rewrite. status now reports the ledger state
corroborated by the account's real expiry — passwd -S read L for everyone
(apply locks all passwords always), so its locked/active was meaningless —
and flags a mismatch loudly as drift.
- Perms are part of the converged state: ~/.ssh and authorized_keys ownership
and mode converge on every run, not only when content changes — StrictModes
treats them as load-bearing, so drifted perms were a broken login that
"already converged" lied about. Only the content write stays cmp-guarded.
- close-root's admin-door gate checks the StrictModes shape per candidate —
ownership, group/world-writability of home/.ssh/authorized_keys, a real
login shell, an unexpired account — and names which check failed. It proves
the door SHOULD open, not that it does; the separate-session advisory stays
load-bearing.
- Usernames are validated in the parser's one-pass refusal matrix
(^[a-z_][a-z0-9_-]{0,31}$): 'fo|o' corrupted the parser's own '|'-delimited
stream, and a leading '-' read as a useradd flag mid-convergence.
- The box role is trait-aware: on a host=no box an absent incus group skips
the role with a warning and converges everything else — one box-role user
in a fleet-wide file must not abort apply everywhere VMs don't live.
host=yes still dies pointing at box setup-host; a classless marker warns
toward a bootstrap re-run.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
class decides root SSH's fate, and this is human's: install
/etc/ssh/sshd_config.d/00-rig-users.conf (PermitRootLogin no), where the NAME
is the mechanism — sshd_config is first-wins, the Include glob expands
lexically, and '-' sorts before '.', so it is read before bootstrap's
00-rig.conf and wins. Gated three ways, no --force: a marker must exist
(never shut the root door blind), it must say class=human (on a server root
is the control plane's automation identity — closing it severs fleet
management), and some rig-admin member must already hold a non-empty
authorized_keys (never close the only door). The gate's policy lives in the
lib as assert_marker_human so the harness proves every refusal against
fixture markers as non-root; RIG_ROLE_MARKER keeps the command pointable at
the same fixtures. Apply is bootstrap's validate-then-apply shape verbatim —
cmp-guard, sshd -t on the merged config before the restart with rollback,
then the sshd -T effective assertion. Bootstrap's own permitrootlogin
assertion widens to accept 'no': the closed door is strictly harder, never
broken, and by first-wins bootstrap cannot reopen it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operators become a declared fact, not an accumulation of adduser runs: a
line-based, bash-parseable users file (no YAML, no jq — a rig box has
neither) names each user, their roles, and their keys, and apply converges
the box to exactly that. Roles map to groups (admin→rig-admin with full
NOPASSWD sudo, rig→rig sudo for the rig binary only, box→incus with no
sudo — box's setup-host owns Incus, rig only asserts the group). Every
password stays locked always; the SSH key at the door is the
authentication. A user dropped from the file is found via the /etc/rig/users
ledger and locked, never deleted — deleting frees the uid and rots
attribution. The sudoers drop-in lands only after visudo -c passes, because
a bad file under sudoers.d takes down all of sudo. Class never gates apply
(#26: a shared root login is unattributable, so operators belong on every
class); the marker only colors what root SSH does next. The whole file is
validated in one pass before the root check, every error named with its
line, so refusals are provable in the non-root harness through the sourced
parser.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
