@codex-reviewer-andresmgsl's five points. Three were correctness, and one of
them found that my must-fail cases could not fail.
1. THE OBJECT IS MANDATORY. UNVERIFIABLE-HERE is gone: a missing ref, an absent
object and a non-ancestor are three distinct refusals. The ref is now the
FULL 40-character SHA, and ci.yml fetches exactly that object before the
suite. "Runs offline" means the TEST reads local evidence; it never meant CI
may omit the evidence and pass.
2. THE SCAN COVERS WHAT THE INVENTORY CLAIMS. It walked shell under four globs
and never looked at workflows, .github/labels.conf or drills/ — three
categories the inventory governs. Widened, and it immediately found four
real blind spots on merged main: refs-not-closing's declaration,
labels.yml's inline forge decision, refs-guard.yml's GitHub-only scheduling
and release-exercise.yml's pinned CEREMONY_FORGE. All four are now inventory
entries with the issue that removes them, because a delta location with no
exit is indistinguishable from one nobody noticed. A file that DECLARES a
client is no longer exempt as a "consumer" — only files that merely CALL the
shim are.
3. THE TEETH NOW DRIVE THE GUARD. They asserted the predicates separately and
never invoked no_unlisted, so the guard could have been `return 0` and both
must-fail rows would still have passed. SCAN_ROOT is a parameter now and the
cases build a tree, add an unlisted decider — shell AND workflow, so
coverage cannot regress to the old glob — and assert the real top-level
check fails naming it. Replacing no_unlisted with `return 0` reds five.
4. PATH MATCHING, NOT PREFIX MATCHING. `drills/` accepted `drills-old/x` and
`lib/forge.sh` accepted `lib/forge.sh.backup`. Exact for files, `dir/` for
directories, with both negative boundaries covered.
5. THE IMMUTABLE SHA IS CAPTURED AT FETCH. The runbook now takes
upstream_sha=$(git rev-parse gh/main) once and merges and records that
value. This is not hypothetical: while this PR was in review upstream moved
from 8c3a4d1 to 08e2912, and re-reading gh/main at recording time would have
written a commit this tree does not contain. I caught that by walking into
it.
test/run.sh 29/29; upstream-delta 21/21; shellcheck 0.10.0, actionlint,
changelog-armed clean.
Refs #200
@codex-reviewer-andresmgsl's two additions (#5697), both measured in the #198
sync rather than anticipated.
Every branch open across a sync is stale afterwards: Forgejo never re-tests an
open PR when main moves under it, so #206 and #207's green 22-file suites were
about a tree that no longer existed once the 28-file one landed — and #206's
fragment was individually green while making the combined tree red under a rule
the sync itself introduces. The runbook now says to update each in-flight
branch from the newly synced main, or check them in a scratch merge, and that a
prior approval is evidence about the tree it was given on.
And post-merge runs are audited by executed steps, never by colour: inventory
what the sync changed about triggers and jobs, read which job actually ran, and
treat a green refusal path as evidence for that path only. Run 326 was green
and had reconciled nothing.
Both failures happened with the no-runtime-gh guard green and CI green, so the
runbook says that too.
Refs #200
The third child of #197, written immediately after performing the sync it
describes, while the findings are still first-hand.
docs/UPSTREAM-SYNC.md carries the procedure and the six standing resolutions,
each with the issue that decided it, so they are not re-argued every sync. The
parts that are not obvious from the outside, and that the 0.6.0 sync paid to
learn:
* THE AUDIT STEP. `git merge` takes upstream's side wherever only upstream
moved a region, so a function upstream ADDED to a file this tree owns
arrives with no conflict and no question. Reviewing the hunks cannot find
it — four reviewers read the same diff and each found a different subset.
That was eight runtime `gh` call sites in three files and two file types.
* THE SAME MECHANIC APPLIES TO STATE. A resolved region can remove a producer
whose consumers auto-merged, and those consumers degrade to empty rather
than erroring, so nothing goes red. Three such seams in one sync.
* VERIFY WHERE IT RUNS. "Green locally" was wrong three times, for three
different reasons: shellcheck-all lints TRACKED files so a new file's first
lint is meaningless; CI pins shellcheck 0.10.0; and the runner's jq 1.6
exits 0 where 1.7 exits 4 on `jq -e` with empty input — which was not a
test problem but a guard accepting an unreadable read.
* TEST THE MERGE RESULT. Forgejo tests heads, never what two branches produce
together, and two green PRs did produce a red tree in this sync.
* AFTER MERGING, CHECK THE SWEEP RECONCILED SOMETHING. The first post-merge
run was green and had done nothing.
.upstream-ref records the carried commit in machine-readable form beside the
CHANGELOG's prose. test/upstream-delta.test.sh asserts every forge-DECIDING
file is named in the inventory — offline, comment-aware, and refusing rather
than skipping when the ref is missing. Shim CONSUMERS are allowed by name, so
a seventh consumer is silent and a seventh decider is not.
docs/CONSUMERS.md now states that two ceremonies answer to the same version
number and how a consumer says which one it pinned.
Must-fail, both from the issue's test plan: scattering a forge_detect branch
into an unlisted file reds the guard; blanking .upstream-ref reds it too.
test/run.sh 29 files 0 failed under jq 1.7 and jq 1.6; shellcheck 0.10.0,
actionlint, self-ref, marker, vendored and changelog-armed all clean.
Refs #200
`git merge` of upstream `8c3a4d1` onto `dad99dd`, common ancestor `84bb1a4`.
18 hunks in 10 files; `lib/forge.sh`, `lib/forge-github.sh` and
`lib/forge-forgejo.sh` conflict in none and come out byte-identical.
The resolutions the issue decided: VERSION and both CEREMONY_SELF_REF
carriers take upstream's numbers; `.github/labels.conf` and `drills/0.4.1.md`
keep this forge's; CHANGELOG keeps both sides and names the upstream commit
this tree carries.
The part the hunks did not contain. Upstream's 0.5.0/0.6.0 work added whole
functions to files this tree already owned, so `git merge` took its side
without raising a conflict — and with them, EIGHT runtime `gh` call sites
that #188 had removed. Seven are ported onto the shim: two reads and four
comment writes in issueflow-reconcile, and labels-reconcile's HEAD_COMMIT_AT
read. The eighth is `gh workflow run` in labels.yml, which a workflow cannot
declare a client for and whose Forgejo equivalent this instance answers with
500 rather than a 4xx — named with its reason rather than ported on a guess.
test/no-runtime-gh.test.sh makes the rule mechanical, because reviewing the
diff could not: four reviewers reading it each found a different subset, and
the contract suite stubs `gh`, so a reintroduced call site passes it.
Three seams the resolution decides are silent when resolved wrongly, and each
now has a case that fails on the wrong one: the merged record's `merged_at`
third column (without it every sort key ties and the highest PR number comes
back), the open gather's one-BODY-row-per-line feed (a whole decoded body as
one record loses every declaration including the first), and the whole-board
read whose COLLISION_FLAGS/WINDOW_FLAGS consumers auto-merged.
The open gather carries CLOSING rows as well as BODY rows. `Refs` alone would
drop every `Closes #N` link on the open side and reclaim a claim the PR was
holding — the existing base64 round-trip case is red without it.
actions/refs-not-closing declares CEREMONY_FORGE_CLIENT=gh: its only gather
is GraphQL, which Forgejo does not serve at all. #199 ports it.
test/run.sh: 28 test files, 0 failed. shellcheck and actionlint clean.
Refs #198
Thirty-five fragments assembled into '## 0.6.0 — 2026-08-05'; VERSION to
bare 0.6.0; the three CEREMONY_SELF_REF carriers stamped "0.6.0" in this
one commit; the three docs/CONSUMERS.md availability markers cleared to
name 0.6.0 — refs-not-closing (#218), the RELEASES.md mirror entry (#248)
and the vendored-manifest completeness guarantee (#251).
drills/0.6.0.md opens with the measurement that decides its shape: the
doors-unchanged conditions do NOT all hold at this candidate, because
lib/changelog.sh moved on the release path since the last rehearsed tag
0.4.0. A full disposable-repo rehearsal is owed and is in progress; the
record is committed early and filled from the runs as they happen.
Refs #249.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Both findings are @codex's on !193 (#1583), and both are real.
The asset name travels as a QUERY VALUE, and the artifact-hook contract
permits any file the consumer drops in RELEASE_ASSETS_DIR. Raw
interpolation meant `release asset.tgz` made curl reject the URL outright
(exit 3), and '&', '#', '+', '%' silently changed the name or the query's
shape. `gh release create` handled all of those, so a 1:1 port had to.
Encoded through one boundary — jq's @uri, since jq is already a hard
dependency of this backend and a hand-rolled sed class is how the next
unescaped character gets through. Six backend cases cover it: the encoder
on a space and on the delimiters, uploads under both names, the created
release id in the path, and the multipart attachment. Mutation-checked:
dropping the encoder fails exactly the two name assertions.
docs/CONSUMERS.md's artifact-hook recovery still told operators to "run
`gh release create` by hand" and described the hook as running "before
`gh release create`" — on a Forgejo runner that is precisely the failure
this PR fixes. It now names the forge-neutral tag-door recovery first and
shows both clients for the manual path, without regressing the GitHub
guidance.
1035 assertions, 22 suites, shellcheck-all and actionlint clean.
Refs #191
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
docs/VENDORED.txt and actions/docs-sync/docs-sync.sh entered the tree in
the same commit and are byte-identical at every tag — blobs 10c20a3c and
ba426479 at 0.1.0 through 0.5.0 — and 0.1.0's copy of the tool is already
manifest-driven (MANIFEST="docs/VENDORED.txt", L75). Citing 0.5.0 told the
0.1.0-0.4.1 tail, which is exactly the population this section is written
for, that the manifest was unavailable at its pin, so it would keep the
hardcoded list: #251's failure mode reproduced by the document that exists
to abolish it. The same file already said 0.1.0 at L131-L133.
Also make the guard's tracked-ness skip announce itself. It degrades to
"not asserted" wherever the tree is not a git work tree root, and doing
that in silence is the shape this script's own header argues against, so
the skip now prints on both output paths, green and red, with a test row
each way.
Round 1: claude blocking point, and claude nit 3.
Re-vendor tooling and docs-sync equivalents read the pin docs/VENDORED.txt
(available at 0.5.0 and later) instead of naming the doc set themselves, so
a new doctrine file reaches every consumer at its next ordinary pin bump
with zero list edits. A hardcoded list propagates nothing and its
staleness is silent: docs-sync --check asserts byte-identity for the files
the list names and says nothing about one it omits.
What makes reading the manifest sufficient rather than merely better is
the self-guard this PR adds, tagged unreleased until the first tag carries
it, per the RELEASES.md paragraph above it.
Refs #251
Five fragments assembled into '## 0.5.0 — 2026-08-03' (#205#216#221#224#226); VERSION to bare 0.5.0; the three CEREMONY_SELF_REF carriers
stamped "0.5.0" in this one commit; the panel-rows unreleased marker in
docs/CONSUMERS.md cleared to name 0.5.0; drills/0.5.0.md records the
doors-unchanged ruling with the measurements as they are at 0ac3a6f.
Refs #233.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Term 4. GitHub clears requested_reviewers when a verdict lands, so the field
answers "who still owes a verdict" by itself. Forgejo never clears it —
measured: rig!140 listed all three panelists with all three verdicts in, and
rig!146 still lists three while MERGED, so the field is stale even on a
closed PR.
Read raw on Forgejo that is not a cosmetic over-count. `requested` drives
three decisions, and a permanently-true field pins a PR at
state:bots-reviewing for life and stops blocker:unrequested from ever being
true: the sweep believes a round is live forever and no staleness can
correct it.
So the requested set is intersected with who has NOT submitted a verdict for
the current head, derived from /pulls/{n}/reviews — the read that is true on
both forges. On GitHub the filter removes nothing, because the field is
already accurate; term 5 holds by construction rather than by care.
A STALE approval — an approval of an older head — still owes a verdict. That
is the case that matters: treating it as answered would let a stale round
read as complete, which is the shape #136 exists to prevent.
Mutation-verified both ways: reading the field raw again reds three cases,
and treating STALE as answered reds two.
Also documents @grok-reviewer-andresmgsl's ask (#4763): every panel= account
must be able to read the repo, or the forge refuses the review request —
422 naming the account on Forgejo. A real failure mode for private
consumers, and it fails loudly rather than sweeping blind.
Refs #188
The reorder let a draft with a live human request plus a standing block
or comment fall through to round_state, whose human-request precedence
sits above BLOCK/FEEDBACK — 224 of claude's 1500 fixture cases read
needs-human on a PR GitHub cannot merge. decide_state now disqualifies
needs-human unconditionally under DRAFT=true, landing on
state:addressing like the blocker/needs-ruling/blocked clauses. The two
new rows assert the criterion where it can actually fail: human
requested x {CHANGES_REQUESTED, COMMENTED}. Also grok's nit: the
bootstrap row for state:building now matches LABELS.md (draft is
evidence, not the definition), and the CONSUMERS.md reflow nits are in.
Refs #205
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Each marker now says available-at-tag in the guide's existing L420
phrasing, verified by tag containment in #221; every never-mix-refs
sentence survives verbatim. The convention paragraph gains its missing
half: the release PR that ships machinery clears, in that same PR,
every marker its assembled section makes false.
Refs #221
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
One resolution point (panel_for_author) feeds set_required_bots; the
author's row when the conf defines one, the base panel= otherwise, minus
the author in either case. Bracket prefixes are matched quoted so the
case patterns cannot glob (D7, panela= tripwire). configured_label_rows
skips the rows so a dispatch bootstrap cannot mint a label named after
one. BUILDER.md/REVIEWER.md carry the one D9 wording; CONSUMERS.md
publishes the row as unreleased with the parse-failure warning.
Refs #224
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
crew#250 verified two facts the design prose now carries: a queue-
displaced run is not independently rerunnable (gh run rerun / --failed /
--job all refuse), so a victim PR had no manual escape hatch; and the
displacing burst is deterministic — one review_requested event per
panelist per request — so displacement is the steady state of a working
fleet, scaling with panel size, not a traffic spike.
CONSUMERS.md now walks the adoption as one atomic four-edit PR with crew
as the worked example: the pin bump in every ceremony uses: reference,
the new labels-sweep.yml caller, the cron RELOCATED (bold warning: a
copied-not-moved schedule double-fires sweeps into the one shared group
and reads as the bug getting worse after the fix), and actions: write
replacing the labels caller's actions: read.
Refs #209
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The sweep rode the same workflow run as the PR event that woke it, so
every displacement in the shared labels-reconcile queue recorded a
CANCELLED reconcile check on some PR — fake red CI that held review
requests. The reconcile + issueflow jobs move, unchanged, to a new
reusable labels-sweep.yml behind their own caller; labels.yml gains a
trigger job that dispatches the consumer's sweep caller with the plain
GITHUB_TOKEN (workflow_dispatch is a documented no-retrigger exemption)
on every event that used to run reconcile. A displaced sweep now cancels
on the Actions tab, attached to no PR; PR checks show scope + trigger.
Because every trigger-driven wake arrives as workflow_dispatch, the event
name alone no longer separates the operator's manual bootstrap from an
event-woken sweep: the sweep caller's bootstrap dispatch input does — the
trigger passes no, a bare manual dispatch defaults to yes. The sweep
reusable also takes pr_workflow_name, exported as SELF_WORKFLOW for the
#208 reconciler (harmless to earlier ones; zero file overlap with #208).
The trigger is deliberately loud: a pin bumped without the sweep caller,
its bootstrap input, or actions: write on the labels caller goes red at
the trigger job instead of silently never sweeping again — documented in
docs/CONSUMERS.md with the split stubs and the atomic-adoption note.
Refs #209
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The trigger comments, CONSUMERS stub, changelog, and reusable labels.yml
comment said "events carry every real state change in seconds; the cron
only backstops a forgotten handoff." That is backwards: no subscribed
event wakes this sweep for a review verdict landing (no pull_request_review
trigger), blocker:ci-red set/cleared, blocker:conflict when another PR
merges, or the time-based stale/48h-reclaim. The hourly cron is the sole
discovery path for those four classes, not a forgotten-handoff net —
so the comments now name them and warn against deleting the cron (AC5).
codex-2 / kimi-2 (both blocking, round 2 @0a812c4b).
Round fixes on #200.
codex-1 (blocking): the issues narrowing dropped `edited`/`reopened`, but both
carry a queue-state change an event uniquely carries — `edited` a body rewrite
of the `Blocked by #N` declaration the sweep parses
(issueflow-reconcile.sh:179), `reopened` a closed issue re-entering the queue.
Dropping them tripped #199's must-fail. Narrow to
`[opened, closed, edited, reopened]`, dropping only the churn/validation
actions labeled/unlabeled/assigned/unassigned. Trigger tests now pin
edited/reopened present and the four dropped; labels.test.sh exact-list updated.
kimi (blocking): the "supersedes unreleased #144" prose was false — #144's
edited/reopened shipped in 0.3.0. Dissolved: we now keep them. CONSUMERS prose
rewritten to the real version history (0.2.0 #32 / 0.3.0 #144 / #199 narrows),
and the #137 review-request line corrected from "unreleased" to shipped-in-0.3.0.
kimi (non-blocking): reusable labels.yml comment no longer cites */15.
codex-2 (AC1 after-measurement / closing) escalated to triage on #199 — held,
not guessed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Bring the published caller stub to the #199 shape in lockstep with
self-labels.yml (preserving the stub<->caller parity #144 established):
hourly cron, issues: [opened, closed], per-trigger why-comments. Rewrite
the adoption prose — 0.2.0 shipped the broad set; #199 narrows it at its
pin bump and supersedes the unreleased edited/reopened additions (#144).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
167/175 gain '### Added', 173/178 '### Changed', 180 '### Fixed' — every
bullet byte-identical, headings only (the #158 bar, inverted). CONSUMERS.md
names the sentinel and the flip procedure; changelog.d/README.md names the
sentinel. 182.md is this PR's own fragment, grouped atop the sentinel it
ships.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The stub published [opened, labeled, unlabeled, assigned, unassigned,
closed] while ceremony's own caller listens on eight types — PR #32's
70db91f widened the caller by edited and reopened and the stub never
followed. Both are load-bearing: an edited body rewrites the Blocked-by
declaration the reconcile sweep parses, and a reopened issue re-enters
the queue wearing labels derived at close (#144).
The stub's list is now byte-identical to the caller's, a parity row in
test/labels.test.sh keeps it that way (red on a dropped type, a drift,
or a reorder in one file only), and one adoption note names the tag the
widened list rides in on. The caller does not narrow.
Closes#144
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The three sites called ceremony#32 machinery unreleased after 0.2.0
(tagged 2026-07-24) became the first tag carrying it: the in-stub comment
above the issues: block, the issues: adoption paragraph, and the
triage-actors= paragraph. All three now state availability at 0.2.0 and
later; the 0.1.0-omission guidance and the parse-failure sentence stay —
still true. No type list moves (the caller/stub issues: subset drift is
#144, not this PR).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The reconciler's rule was right and blind: the caller never listened on
review_requested/review_request_removed, so the one event that falsifies
(or restores) blocker:unrequested could not clear it, and a quiet repo
wore the red flag until the advisory cron (#137's timeline: 93 seconds,
cleared only by an unrelated PR's push).
- self-labels.yml + the CONSUMERS.md stub gain both types; the scope job
skips them (no paths change; running labeler there widens #130's window)
- test/labels.test.sh: caller/stub parity row with mutation cases —
dropped type either side, one-sided reorder, all red
- CONSUMERS.md no longer claims trigger adoption is a bare pin bump; the
pending stub edit is named and rides the first tag carrying ceremony#137
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Bootstrap arms with a preamble plus changelog.d/, the guard list gains
changelog-assembled, the conversion checklist gains the fragment
conversion, the changelog rule is fragment-first with the legacy floor
kept for unconverted pins, and the assembly command block gives a reader
everything needed to produce a section (#112 D12, #117).
LABELS.md's needs-ruling paragraph gains the bare-flag check and the
markerless 7-day nudge; CONSUMERS.md names them in the labels job and
states the caller stub is unchanged since #18 (a pin bump is the whole
upgrade); one CHANGELOG line under Unreleased (#52).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Round 1 (PR #48): codex-bot flagged the release-only bump described as a
one-line uses change while the same-tag rule two bullets up requires every
reference on one tag — a release-only setup has four (release caller +
three guards), so a one-line bump splits the consumer across versions.
The bump bullet and the pin-bump procedure now both require every ceremony
uses: reference updated together. Also the README called lib/decide.sh a
5-state table; the spec comment and rendered table have six rows.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Extends the existing release-workflow / artifact-hook / labels sections
(from #27 and #39, kept intact) with the remaining adoption guide: the
greenfield bootstrap path, the box/rig/cast conversion checklist, the
exact-tag pinning policy, the portable changelog contributor rule, and
the agent-team-flow adoption checklist with the pin-bump procedure
(docs-sync documented from #19's contract).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
