heavy-duty/ceremony

Fork 2

docs: a park is declared once and stands; a nothing-changed resumption posts nothing #179

Merged

claude-bot-andresmgsl merged 1 commit from build/178-park-stands into main

2026-07-25 07:02:52 +00:00

claude-bot-andresmgsl commented

2026-07-25 04:27:21 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Closes #178

Extends the "A park is declared, never inferred" bullet in BUILDER.md (Claiming) with the three facts decided on discussion #177, and adds changelog.d/178.md. Prose only — no machinery, no new label.

Acceptance criteria

BUILDER.md states a park is declared once and stands until its facts change, and that a resumption finding nothing changed posts nothing
BUILDER.md names what re-opens the duty to comment, and the no-open-PR / 48-hour refresh exception with its cadence
No change outside BUILDER.md and changelog.d/ — no machinery, no new label
Read-through holds: rig#145 (parked, PR open, nothing changed at resume) → post nothing; a no-PR park → refresh inside 48h; a claim simply not being worked on → abandonment, not park (the abandonment bullet is untouched and the new text ends by saying so explicitly)

Worklog

Claim #178, create worktree/branch
Extend the park-declaration bullet in BUILDER.md with the three facts
Write changelog.d/178.md (passes changelog_fragment_problem locally)
Self read-through against the three scenarios in the acceptance criteria
Mark ready-for-review, request the panel

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Closes #178 Extends the **"A park is declared, never inferred"** bullet in BUILDER.md (Claiming) with the three facts decided on discussion #177, and adds `changelog.d/178.md`. Prose only — no machinery, no new label. ## Acceptance criteria - [x] BUILDER.md states a park is declared once and stands until its facts change, and that a resumption finding nothing changed posts nothing - [x] BUILDER.md names what re-opens the duty to comment, and the no-open-PR / 48-hour refresh exception with its cadence - [x] No change outside BUILDER.md and `changelog.d/` — no machinery, no new label - [x] Read-through holds: rig#145 (parked, PR open, nothing changed at resume) → *post nothing*; a no-PR park → *refresh inside 48h*; a claim simply not being worked on → abandonment, not park (the abandonment bullet is untouched and the new text ends by saying so explicitly) ## Worklog - [x] Claim #178, create worktree/branch - [x] Extend the park-declaration bullet in BUILDER.md with the three facts - [x] Write `changelog.d/178.md` (passes `changelog_fragment_problem` locally) - [x] Self read-through against the three scenarios in the acceptance criteria - [x] Mark ready-for-review, request the panel 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

danmt (Migrated from github.com) reviewed 2026-07-25 04:27:21 +00:00

claude-bot-andresmgsl commented

2026-07-25 04:30:49 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

⟲ resuming from 9ff8ed6c03

⟲ resuming from 9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470

codex-bot-andresmgsl commented

2026-07-25 04:35:45 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

🔎 reviewing head 9ff8ed6c03

🔎 reviewing head 9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470

grok-bot-andresmgsl commented

2026-07-25 04:35:54 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

🔎 reviewing head 9ff8ed6c03

🔎 reviewing head 9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470

codex-bot-andresmgsl (Migrated from github.com) approved these changes 2026-07-25 04:36:38 +00:00

codex-bot-andresmgsl (Migrated from github.com) left a comment

Verified at 9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470:

changelog_fragment_problem changelog.d/178.md
test/changelog.test.sh — 65 passed, 0 failed
git diff --check 486bbd10a49b25a6169cab42a2e89601d5593141..HEAD
GitHub checks for the head are green.

The implementation satisfies #178's acceptance criteria. The added BUILDER.md text makes the declaration persistent, makes an unchanged resumption silent, enumerates the fact changes that reopen the comment duty, preserves the no-open-PR 48-hour refresh exception, and explicitly keeps ordinary stalled claims under abandonment. The diff is limited to BUILDER.md and the required changelog fragment. Verified at `9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470`: - `changelog_fragment_problem changelog.d/178.md` - `test/changelog.test.sh` — 65 passed, 0 failed - `git diff --check 486bbd10a49b25a6169cab42a2e89601d5593141..HEAD` - GitHub checks for the head are green.

kimi-bot-andresmgsl commented

2026-07-25 04:37:40 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

🔎 reviewing head 9ff8ed6c03

🔎 reviewing head 9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470

grok-bot-andresmgsl (Migrated from github.com) approved these changes 2026-07-25 04:37:47 +00:00

grok-bot-andresmgsl (Migrated from github.com) left a comment

Verdict: approve

Reviewed head 9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470 against #178 (acceptance criteria and discussion #177 facts).

What I verified

Diff scope: only BUILDER.md and changelog.d/178.md — no machinery, no new label.
CI on this head: test, self-guards, action-exercise, docs-sync-exercise, labels / reconcile, labels / scope, release-exercise fixtures — all green/pass (call jobs skipped as expected).
Fragment: changelog.d/178.md is a flat bullet under 300 characters and names #178.

Acceptance criteria

Declaration stands; nothing-changed resumption posts nothing — stated in the extended park bullet: stands until facts change; silence while parked is compliant, not abandonment-shaped. met
What re-opens comment + no-open-PR 48h refresh — facts changing (wait resolves/changes hands, shape changes, unpark) each owe one new comment; only a no-open-PR park refreshes inside the reclaim window, at reclaim cadence not duty-loop cadence. met
Scope — BUILDER.md + changelog.d only. met
Read-through
- rig#145 shape (parked, PR open, nothing changed at resume) → post nothing — explicit.
- no-PR park → refresh inside 48h — explicit.
- claim simply not worked on → abandonment, not park — abandonment bullet untouched; new prose ends by saying so. met

Prose-only change; no local test suite beyond reading. Hygiene relies on green CI.

No blocking findings. Non-blocking: none material.

## Verdict: approve Reviewed head `9ff8ed6c035e469928b58cbaaeffc36329f05470` against #178 (acceptance criteria and discussion #177 facts). ### What I verified - **Diff scope:** only `BUILDER.md` and `changelog.d/178.md` — no machinery, no new label. - **CI on this head:** `test`, `self-guards`, `action-exercise`, `docs-sync-exercise`, `labels / reconcile`, `labels / scope`, release-exercise fixtures — all green/pass (call jobs skipped as expected). - **Fragment:** `changelog.d/178.md` is a flat bullet under 300 characters and names #178. ### Acceptance criteria 1. **Declaration stands; nothing-changed resumption posts nothing** — stated in the extended park bullet: stands until facts change; silence while parked is compliant, not abandonment-shaped. **met** 2. **What re-opens comment + no-open-PR 48h refresh** — facts changing (wait resolves/changes hands, shape changes, unpark) each owe one new comment; only a no-open-PR park refreshes inside the reclaim window, at reclaim cadence not duty-loop cadence. **met** 3. **Scope** — BUILDER.md + changelog.d only. **met** 4. **Read-through** - rig#145 shape (parked, PR open, nothing changed at resume) → *post nothing* — explicit. - no-PR park → *refresh inside 48h* — explicit. - claim simply not worked on → abandonment, not park — abandonment bullet untouched; new prose ends by saying so. **met** Prose-only change; no local test suite beyond reading. Hygiene relies on green CI. No blocking findings. Non-blocking: none material.

kimi-bot-andresmgsl (Migrated from github.com) approved these changes 2026-07-25 04:37:49 +00:00

kimi-bot-andresmgsl (Migrated from github.com) left a comment

Approve — head 9ff8ed6.

Prose-only doctrine change closing #178. Verified in a detached worktree at the head SHA; every acceptance criterion checked against the actual text:

Declaration stands / nothing-changed resumption posts nothing — BUILDER.md:87-90: "Declared once, the declaration stands until the park's facts change: a resumption that finds nothing changed posts nothing … silence while parked is compliant, not abandonment-shaped." ✓
What re-opens the duty + the 48h exception with cadence — BUILDER.md:93-100: facts changing (wait resolves or changes hands, shape changes, unpark), each owing one new comment; the no-open-PR park owes a refresh "before the window closes," cadence "the reclaim window's, not any duty loop's." Matches the issue's three facts verbatim in substance. ✓
Scope — diff touches only BUILDER.md and changelog.d/178.md; no machinery, no new label. ✓
Read-through — rig#145 (parked, PR open, nothing changed) → post nothing; a no-PR park → refresh inside 48h; a never-parked claim that stopped moving → the abandonment bullet (BUILDER.md:122-124) is untouched, and the new text ends by saying so explicitly ("abandoned, not silent"). ✓

Checks I ran: changelog_fragment_problem changelog.d/178.md — clean, 196 bytes (under #167's 300-char bound); test/changelog.test.sh — 65 passed, 0 failed; the inserted prose sits inside the park bullet with correct indentation and leaves the surrounding bullets intact. CI at the head is green (test, self-guards, all exercise workflows). Nothing I could not verify — this is prose, and the behavior proof is the read-through, which holds.

Nice touch: the new text carries its own incident citation (rig#145's 38 audits, #177), per the repo's comments-carry-why convention.

**Approve** — head `9ff8ed6`. Prose-only doctrine change closing #178. Verified in a detached worktree at the head SHA; every acceptance criterion checked against the actual text: - **Declaration stands / nothing-changed resumption posts nothing** — `BUILDER.md:87-90`: "Declared once, the declaration **stands** until the park's facts change: a resumption that finds nothing changed posts nothing … silence while parked is compliant, not abandonment-shaped." ✓ - **What re-opens the duty + the 48h exception with cadence** — `BUILDER.md:93-100`: facts changing (wait resolves or changes hands, shape changes, unpark), each owing one new comment; the no-open-PR park owes a refresh "before the window closes," cadence "the reclaim window's, not any duty loop's." Matches the issue's three facts verbatim in substance. ✓ - **Scope** — diff touches only `BUILDER.md` and `changelog.d/178.md`; no machinery, no new label. ✓ - **Read-through** — rig#145 (parked, PR open, nothing changed) → post nothing; a no-PR park → refresh inside 48h; a never-parked claim that stopped moving → the abandonment bullet (`BUILDER.md:122-124`) is untouched, and the new text ends by saying so explicitly ("abandoned, not silent"). ✓ Checks I ran: `changelog_fragment_problem changelog.d/178.md` — clean, 196 bytes (under #167's 300-char bound); `test/changelog.test.sh` — 65 passed, 0 failed; the inserted prose sits inside the park bullet with correct indentation and leaves the surrounding bullets intact. CI at the head is green (`test`, `self-guards`, all exercise workflows). Nothing I could not verify — this is prose, and the behavior proof is the read-through, which holds. Nice touch: the new text carries its own incident citation (rig#145's 38 audits, #177), per the repo's comments-carry-why convention.

claude-bot-andresmgsl commented

2026-07-25 04:43:17 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Round summary — handing off

What shipped. The "A park is declared, never inferred" bullet in BUILDER.md (Claiming) now carries the three facts decided on #177: a park declaration is made once and stands until the park's facts change; a resumption that finds nothing changed posts nothing — silence while parked is compliant, with rig#145's 38 nothing-changed audits cited as the flood this prevents; and the duty to comment re-opens only when the facts change (the named wait resolves or changes hands, the parked shape changes, or the claim unparks), each owing one new comment. The one exception is spelled out: a parked claim with no open PR still feeds the 48-hour reclaim clock, so the builder refreshes the declaration before that window closes — the only repeat a park ever owes, on the reclaim window's cadence, not a duty loop's. The text ends by re-affirming the untouched abandonment rule: a claim never parked that simply stopped moving is abandoned, not silent. Plus changelog.d/178.md. Prose only — no machinery, no new label, nothing outside BUILDER.md and changelog.d/.

Rounds. One round. The panel (codex, grok, kimi) reviewed head 9ff8ed6 and all three approved with no changes requested; the head never moved after ready-for-review, so what was approved is what merges.

Verified.

All CI green on 9ff8ed6: test, self-guards, action-exercise, docs-sync-exercise, release-exercise (fixture-chain, step-replay consumer + dogfood), labels scope + reconcile.
changelog.d/178.md passes changelog_fragment_problem.
Read-through against the acceptance scenarios holds: rig#145-shaped resume (parked, PR open, nothing changed) → post nothing; a no-PR park → refresh inside 48h; a claim that was never parked and stopped moving → abandonment, untouched.
Mergeable right now: zero blocker:*, merge state CLEAN, whole panel approved the current head.

Post-merge residue. None. changelog.d/178.md rides the normal fragment assembly at the next release; no follow-up issues, no cross-repo work.

Requesting @danmt's review and setting state:needs-human — this PR is yours to merge.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

## Round summary — handing off **What shipped.** The "A park is declared, never inferred" bullet in BUILDER.md (Claiming) now carries the three facts decided on #177: a park declaration is made once and **stands** until the park's facts change; a resumption that finds nothing changed posts nothing — silence while parked is compliant, with rig#145's 38 nothing-changed audits cited as the flood this prevents; and the duty to comment re-opens only when the facts change (the named wait resolves or changes hands, the parked shape changes, or the claim unparks), each owing one new comment. The one exception is spelled out: a parked claim with **no open PR** still feeds the 48-hour reclaim clock, so the builder refreshes the declaration before that window closes — the only repeat a park ever owes, on the reclaim window's cadence, not a duty loop's. The text ends by re-affirming the untouched abandonment rule: a claim never parked that simply stopped moving is abandoned, not silent. Plus `changelog.d/178.md`. Prose only — no machinery, no new label, nothing outside BUILDER.md and `changelog.d/`. **Rounds.** One round. The panel (codex, grok, kimi) reviewed head 9ff8ed6 and all three approved with no changes requested; the head never moved after ready-for-review, so what was approved is what merges. **Verified.** - All CI green on 9ff8ed6: test, self-guards, action-exercise, docs-sync-exercise, release-exercise (fixture-chain, step-replay consumer + dogfood), labels scope + reconcile. - `changelog.d/178.md` passes `changelog_fragment_problem`. - Read-through against the acceptance scenarios holds: rig#145-shaped resume (parked, PR open, nothing changed) → post nothing; a no-PR park → refresh inside 48h; a claim that was never parked and stopped moving → abandonment, untouched. - Mergeable right now: zero `blocker:*`, merge state CLEAN, whole panel approved the current head. **Post-merge residue.** None. `changelog.d/178.md` rides the normal fragment assembly at the next release; no follow-up issues, no cross-repo work. Requesting @danmt's review and setting `state:needs-human` — this PR is yours to merge. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)